Goodreads announced they’ll allow readers to rate books using half and quarter stars this week. This has triggered an emotional outpouring on social media of writers who are terrified it will lower their ratings and readers adamant they don’t care what authors think, readers are whiney, more back and forth, etc.
I’m not very concerned about the Goodreads stars change myself because some of my books already have very low ratings and despite that I’ve been able to find readers. Nevertheless, I sympathize with authors who are worried about this. Marginalized writers often feel they get dinged more than other authors when it comes to ratings. A friend of mine calls this the special tax.
I haven’t run a scientific study on this subject, but I’ve been told more than once that I had too many Spanish names (in books set in Mexico) or that readers felt my books were not didactic enough (they’re not monographies). Other authors don’t have to deal with this excess baggage.
Anyway, social media users have suggested the star system should not affect anyone much because Storygraph allows half stars and marginalized authors tend to have higher ratings there. But this ignores the fact that Storygraph’s user base is different and smaller than Goodreads, and that the two platforms operate differently. Goodreads allows for more natural discovery. It’s also used more frequently by large publishers for promotional efforts. Goodreads is also owned by Amazon and Goodreads ratings show on Amazon pages. Their awards can be important discovery vehicles.
When I talked about the Goodreads awards last year I mentioned that the popular books that made the awards tended to be equally popular on Storygraph.
As I said at that time:
The suggestion that all would be better if we simply moved to Storygraph is disproven once you look quickly at the book stats over there. For example, on Goodreads Mate by Ali Hazelwood has been rated by over 100,000 users, has 19,000 reviews and a rating of 4.18. On Storygraph it is rated 4.23 based on 18,000 reviews. The Wrath of the Fallen by Amber V. Nicole, one of the two Black authors to make the romantasy nominee list, has almost 5,000 ratings on Goodreads, with 1,100 reviews and a rating of 4.42. On Storygraph it has 388 reviews and a score of 4.48. The most popular romantasy novels such as Mate, Onyx Storm or The Irresistible Urge to Fall For Your Enemy are still more popular on Storygraph and would win against most books by authors of color.
A book that has a low rating on Goodreads might have a slightly higher rating on Storygraph but it is likely to have less reviews as seen in the example above.
The rating variations are not hugely significant between platforms. I haven’t bumped into a book by a marginalized author that has a 2.5 rating on Goodreads but hits 4 stars on Storygraph.
On Goodreads, my latest novel, The Intrigue, sits at 3.77 at the moment. It has a 3.91 on Storygraph. The Beautiful Ones is rated 3.84 on Goodreads and 3.88 on Storygraph. Meanwhile, Velvet Was the Night has a 3.51 on Goodreads and 3.54 on Storygraph. I believe genre and general popularity affect these ratings most significantly, with a slight variation in user bases.
This doesn’t mean discrimination doesn’t play a part in ratings, but it is already baked into the system, so to speak. Whether we use Storygraph or Goodreads, the average user is probably less likely to seek books about POC or more likely to judge certain content more harshly. For example, GLBTQ and POC books are often more likely to be banned in schools and therefore they’re probably going to have more polarizing ratings and reviews.
So does this mean authors worried about Goodreads ratings are foolish?
No. Although there is nothing we can do about ratings and although ratings are not the most important factor for a book’s success, authors and publishers pay attention to Goodreads because it is one of the few effective channels for book discovery left.
Many traditional review sites have folded (witness the Washington Post) and the social media that used to get attention has also fragmented or is becoming more and more ineffective. Distribution issues are compounding everything: last year I talked about distribution problems for my novel The Bewitching and once again I’m backordered this year. The book has been very successful and should be easily available in stores right now but it’s not.
This year I have spent more on marketing and publicity than ever in my career. Social media analysis, social media promoted posts, keyword ads, advertising in sites such as CrimeReads and Lit Hub. All this I paid out of pocket. My publisher, DelRey, also spent money on promoting me. The result? The Intrigue has Bookscanned 4,500 copies. That’s approximately how many books in print it has sold. It’s a career low for me despite the huge amounts of resources I’ve spent on it.
Does this mean I’m a worse writer now? That DelRey dislikes me? No. The trade reviews for my novel were good, numerous ARCs were sent out, etc. The Intrigue is not hitting how I’d like it to hit and part of it may simply be its genre. It’s a noir set in the 1940s with a nod to classics such as The Postman Always Rings Twice. That’s not the cultural zeitgeist right now. Plus, we can’t hit home runs all the time. Last year I had a very successful release with The Bewitching which has powered through the year and despite distribution issues has been doing well (and much better in audio than my other titles).
But, the thing is, in general writers are facing tougher times. Tactics that used to be effective don’t work, consumer habits and culture are rapidly changing, visibility is being eroded by a tsunami of books published with AI, and to top it off, since I was talking about distribution Publishers Lunch had a story with even more bad news:
New US tariffs on goods from Canada including paper, higher fuel prices, and the closure of the Coral Graphics plant in New York have all made it harder for publishers to reprint to fill demand, and print books on time in order to hold their original publication dates.
A snowballing number of factors are making it harder and harder for the average writer to sell books. These factors are intensified for marginalized authors who may have a host of extra reasons why their books are floundering. For example, my friends who publish YA have said editors seem less receptive to books with characters who are gay or feature people of color. The talk between us writers of color is we feel this years Latin American Heritage celebrations are very muted and efforts from publishers minimal. There are many factors that are against us.
Which is to say I understand perfectly why some writers are very worried about ratings. I can also see how from the outside for the average reader this may seem like a silly concern.
Ultimately I’m not here to tell you to rate higher or lower, or to assure you there is no cause for anxiety. If you’re a writer, I want to tell you I get it. We’re all a bit neurotic right now. To readers, all I can say is the same thing: we’re all a bit neurotic. Stay kind.
